Interested in arguments, not arguing. Mostly looking at all things sex, gender, politics, identity and trying to work out what it means

Joined September 2021
1,918 Photos and videos
This is quite extraordinary, almost too much to snark about. She will delete this.
County lines are PHONE LINES, not border demarcations. You can’t traffic people over them. The Rape Gang Inquiry Report is junk.
5
Vaguely Rational retweeted
Lets ignore the compete false equivalence for a second, but if you like im happy to strike a deal whereby the English dont do white suprememcy / football holiganism in Pakistan and Pakistanis dont do grooming / cousin marriage in the UK. Everyone's a winner, eh!
2
15
213
I love it when this chap / chapess QT someone new and a whole host of randoms dont get it for the first time. Its like losing my virginity all over again
People are telling me Elon's wealth is tied up in shares. OK then, why doesn't he give every American homeless person $1 million in shares? SpaceX could be governed by a panel of thousands of homeless people instead of just one man.
18
There is a mental health crisis in this country and its epicentre seems to be serving MPs.
LGBT people deserve to be able to live freely and safely. I don't believe the EHRC's guidance is helping to make that possible. My statement on why I've signed EDM 240 to stand up for trans people in my constituency and across the UK.
13
"Openly non-binary"!!! Honestly the very idea that there are 'non-binary' people who wont immediately tell us about it is ludicrous
'When people see people in positions of power who belong to the marginalised identities that they've only seen in quiet corners, there is an element of pride there' Scotland's first openly non-binary MSP has said they hope more transgender people will seek election 👇
1
1
48
"Time and again these single incidents keep happening".....
Politicians who fanned these flames should hang their heads in shame. Time and again we've seen this story play out. Single incidents used to fuel a far right narrative - and communities across the nation paying the price.
14
Lying doesn't seem like a good start for a news channel but may well turn out to be on brand
So there we have it: @Daniel_Sugarman has just called me - a brown skinned woman - and three other journalists of colour incl one with Jewish ancestry - sh*t hires. This is why we need independent media more than ever. @mehdirhasan @zeteo_news
56
Three word on the issue - 2 paragraphs on Farage / far right / weaponisation blah blah. Its almost parody now
Another horrific event. Another weaponisation of an incident with zero information. Farage has actively been responsible for two sets of riots already, but he's still allowed to punt ill-informed, thinly disguised racism from his hiding place.
23
"Actshully this is mainly the fault of the right wing and the English"....
The horrific scenes in North Belfast should not be used by English, right wing politicians to further their own ends. I don’t ever remember them commenting on any of the other hellish things that community has experienced over the years.
14
These people are an embarrassment
Different words. Different context. Different tone.
12
This guy has to be one of the most embarrassing examples of someone desperate for a victim complex despite their overwhelming privilidge. I assume hes leaning into a humiliation fetish just for those sweet oppression points!
Like are you dense?
11
Australia's blindspot for gender woo really is on another level
🟠 BREAKING: CHILD RAPIST SUES VICTORIAN LABOR OVER CONDITIONS IN THE WOMEN'S PRISON LABOR PUT HIM IN 🟠 A man convicted of raping his own 5-year-old daughter, filming the abuse and sending the footage to a US paedophile is now suing the Victorian Labor government over conditions in the women's prison Labor placed him in. WHAT HE DID Anonymised by the court as Hilary Maloney, the offender pleaded guilty in 2024 to three charges: Persistent sexual abuse of a child under 16 (Victorian, max 25 years, standard sentence 10 years) Producing child abuse material via a carriage service (Commonwealth) Transmitting child abuse material via a carriage service (Commonwealth) He offended on at least 19 occasions over 33 days in May and June 2023. The victim was his own 5-year-old daughter. He lived in the same home as her and her mother. He produced 77 files. He sent them to Samuel Booth, a US paedophile he met online in a self-described master and slave dynamic. THE SENTENCE County Court Judge Nola Karapanagiotidis sentenced Maloney to 4 years 9 months. Non parole: 2 years 6 months. The standard sentence for the state offence alone is 10 years. The judge accepted gender dysphoria reduced Maloney's moral culpability. She accepted online manipulation by Booth reduced it further. She said Maloney was "highly unlikely" to reoffend unless coerced again. THE WOMEN'S PRISON Maloney was placed in Dame Phyllis Frost Centre under a Victorian Labor policy that imprisons offenders by gender identity, not sex. The same policy was in place in 2022 when a female prisoner was sexually assaulted by a trans identifying male murderer in another Victorian women's prison. The Allan government settled the victim's claim in secret. THE LAWSUIT Maloney is now suing the Victorian Government over treatment in custody, including 13 months in solitary confinement. The taxpayer pays the damages either way. THE FEDERAL FIX The Coalition's Crimes Amendment (Mandatory Minimum Sentences for Child Sexual Abuse) Bill 2025 would impose a 5-year mandatory minimum on serious federal child sex offences. Albanese Labor has blocked it twice. Maloney is eligible for parole in 2027. His daughter will be 9. Read the full story here: onenewsaustralia.com/trans-p…
10
Vaguely Rational retweeted
“I only did it because I’m susceptible to mass hysteria” isn’t a strong defence
1
4
87
1,850
"Equalities act" klaxon!!!! 📣📣📣📣
It’s worrying how people don’t seem to realise that the only protection from Being fired at work for being gay comes from the equalities act which Reform UK will rip up. Farage has already also said that gay marriage isn’t ’proper marriage’ Wake up, reform UK are homophobes.
2
51
This is an intersting comment (which applies to more religions and indeed groups than just muslims) but - and I mean specifically in the context of philosophical belief which guides behavior in life - surely the HAVE to belive in the same thing. You either follow passage X in the Koran (the you are muslim) or you dont and you are not - i cant quite see how this could be any other way
Muslims don’t all believe one thing. We’re not a hive mind.
28
The replies to this incredibly normal post (which is broadly "im not an expert in a thing so chose not to spout opinions about it") are quite unhinged. I (and I suspect millions of people) took vaccines at the time that we may not do now, nto becuase we are 'cowards' (seems to be the word of choice in the replies!) but because based on prior experiences of life, and a lack of time or willing to rage against EVERY change to law and policy, we sometimes just do these things. The people getting mad at this would, in general, be the first to get mad if someone leftist started asking for tax policy change based on the 'loved experience' of indigenous, 2 spirit folx....
Yes, I had a very severe reaction to my second Moderna shot. But part of being a responsible scientist with a large platform is not extrapolating my personal experience to the entire population. I also have a rare autoimmune condition called Parsonage-Turner syndrome (diagnosed in 2013), so I may have been particularly vulnerable to side effects. Who knows. Given my bad experience with the first mRNA vaccine I've ever taken, I have made the personal decision to avoid them in the future. However, it would have been incredibly unscientific and highly irresponsible of me to take this personal experience of mine and start telling millions of people online to not get vaccinated for COVID. There's a reason quack alternative medicine practitioners plaster personal testimonies all over their websites. They sound convincing to a lot of people. But it's purely manipulation. Personal testimony, even a large collection of them, isn't a substitute for real, population-level data. I am not an expert on vaccines, the COVID vaccine, or epidemiology in general. So when I experience a serious side effect taking something with a non-zero rate of serious side effects, I understand that my personal experience likely isn't an indication that we're all being lied to about safety. You should understand that as well. The impulse to extrapolate a very negative personal experience to the entire population is very strong. But responsible scientists, and especially those with large public platforms, should resist that impulse.
36
Owen clearly knows why testing rate should be adjusted based on underlying population behaviour... and yet sometimes he pretends he doesnt. Truly a mystery.... 🤷‍♂️
Furthermore, shifting to 'population-adjusted' is cynically misleading. Black people are disproportionately stopped, arrested, charged and subjected to force. You have to take that into account, rather than respective population sizes.
51
Vaguely Rational retweeted
Im sure 5Pillars can recommend some rooftop cafes that would be perfect for this type of get-together!
10
14
1,223
13,847
"Vote Green!" "Yes!" "Down with gays!" "Ah... No... Ah actually we are inclusive. We support gay people." "But not people who know gays are bad?" "Well, no. We support everyone." "So we can hate gays?" "No, well... Look, let's just both agree to hate jews. Yes?" "Agreed."
1
8
105
3,975