Some say the "US-Israel Defense Technology Cooperation Initiative" in the new military spending bill is no big deal — that the US and Israel already cooperate closely on defense, so this legislative effort isn't really noteworthy.
A new
@QuincyInst policy note by Steven Simon explains why that's wrong.
Some proponents claim this initiative gives the US access to Israeli military technology it couldn't otherwise obtain. That's simply not true. The United States has been procuring Israeli defense technology for decades. The Iron Dome, the Trophy Active Protection System for Abrams tanks, and Barak missile systems were all acquired under existing, extensive statutory authority.
What the "US-Israel Defense Technology Cooperation Initiative" actually does is create a dedicated executive agent inside the Pentagon — for Israel only — whose authority takes precedence over other DoD component heads, meaning it can overrule agencies like the Defense Technology Security Administration, which manages risks from the international transfer of defense technology and critical information. No comparable bilateral relationship with any other allied nation has this structure.
The dangers go beyond the bias this introduces into defense procurement. Unlike other arrangements, this initiative explicitly contemplates industrial cooperation that would embed Israeli technology within the US defense supply chain — meaning US policymakers would face large costs and time delays should it ever be determined that this arrangement is not working for America. It also risks tethering the US military to its Israeli counterpart technologically in ways that would be difficult to change or question, while making US military support for Israel more opaque. In effect, these efforts would transform assistance into cooperation and shelter the US-Israel relationship from regular congressional votes and oversight.
The result would be a defense relationship that is simultaneously deeper and less transparent.
Read Steven's full analysis:
quincyinst.org/research/coop…