Mumbai desperately needs a sustained, city-wide anti-encroachment drive similar to the ongoing operation in Garib Nagar, Bandra. Illegal constructions on railway land, pavements, and public spaces have choked the city's infrastructure for far too long. Clearing these for essential projects like station expansion is not just about development — it's about safety, rule of law, and the greater public interest.Some are quick to label such actions as "communal." However, an honest examination of ground realities raises uncomfortable questions. Why is it that members of one particular community are disproportionately involved in large-scale encroachments, unauthorized constructions, and illegal hawking across many parts of Mumbai? This is not a baseless claim but a pattern repeatedly observed in enforcement drives.The deeper problem lies in community leadership and internal support. While elites from most other communities actively invest in schools, colleges, scholarships, hospitals, and skill development to uplift their people, a significant section of Muslim elites in India have not demonstrated the same proactive resource-sharing for the socio-economic advancement of their broader community.Mumbai’s educational and charitable landscape reflects this clearly. Communities such as Gujaratis, Marwaris, Parsis, Jains, Marathis, and South Indians have built institutions that drive progress for their own groups and the city at large. Marathis, in particular, have contributed immensely through cooperative movements, educational societies, cultural institutions, and active participation in Mumbai’s industrial and commercial growth over
decades.In contrast, large sections of the Muslim population continue to lag in education, formal employment, and upward mobility — not solely due to external factors, but also due to limited internal initiatives focused on modernization and economic integration.Instead of prioritizing education, skills, and legitimate businesses, some remain trapped in cycles of poverty and parallel social structures. This is worsened by the tendency to invoke “Muslim brotherhood” in welcoming illegal immigration from Bangladesh and elsewhere, which only strains scarce resources, heightens social tensions, and compounds the community’s challenges. Gulf countries and Arab nations, despite their enormous wealth and shared faith, have shown they will never accept such populations in any meaningful numbers — precisely because they understand the heavy economic and social costs
involved.At the end of the day, even as a broader society, we genuinely want to see this community progress and prosper. No one benefits from leaving any group behind, reduced merely to a vote bank for politicians. These leaders extend support when it suits their equations, only to abandon them when political winds shift — leaving the people to face the consequences. Garib Nagar stands as the biggest example of this harsh reality, where many who once backed such settlements have now realigned toward parties and ideologies that prioritize development and enforcement of the law.Rule of law must apply equally to all. Mumbai’s future depends on clearing encroachments, enforcing regulations, and fostering an environment where legal enterprise and hard work are rewarded, irrespective of community. Selective outrage only delays the cleanup the city urgently needs.