What a disingenuous response. Keep in mind these were written right after October 7th which fell right before the camera ready deadline. The events directly impacted the authors who were refused recognition by the ACL leadership for their trauma. despite decades of contributions.
Future rebuttals be like:
Reviewer 2: "Here is the counter-example to the claimed theorem".
Authors: "Reviewer 2 is Hamas and antisemitic".
I don't know about others, but we Indians are used to being called out anti-nationalists for every random thing in the past decade.