The Climate Change Committee's longstanding desire to stamp out meat and dairy consumption is back in the news following their publication of the 7th Carbon Budget -- advice to Parliament and Ed Miliband, which they are very likely (they always do) to adopt without meaningful debate.
They have been trying to do this for a long time. And they have for just as long been trying to find ways to make this acceptable. In 2020, this including convening the Climate Assembly on the belief that the Assembly could stand as a focus group or opinion poll to represent the entire public. They further believed that if they could show that the Assembly supported something, then because the Assembly was selected from ordinary people, the public would accept the Assembly's votes on policy options.
But the Assembly's vote on the reduction of meat and dairy consumption was not a vote as we'd understand it. First, only a third of the assembly were present for the vote. Second, the assembly members were not given the option to vote against anything. The 'voting' consisted of a "Borda count" -- a method in which the "voter" ranks options given to them. The policy of reducing meat and dairy consumption only appeared on less than one third (10/35) of that part of the Assembly's orders of preferences, according to the Borda method.
8 policies were put to the Assembly, and reducing meat and dairy was the second lowest preference:
1. Provide support to farmers: 89%
2. Information and education: 86%
3. Use land efficiently: 66%
4. Rules for large retailers/supermarkets: 46%
5. More local and seasonal food: 40%
6. Make low carbon food affordable: 34%
7. Some, just less, meat [reducing meat and dairy consumption]: 29%
8. Part of planning policy and new developments, including allotments: 14%.
Worse for the CCC, though not counted, comments submitted to the organisers were adamant that policies should not coerce, force, or punish -- i.e. tax -- consumer behaviour.
The convenors of the climate assembly, which includes Parliament itself (the offices, not the members), green NGOs and their billionaire philanthropist grantors, civil servants, and fake academics lied about this underwhelming result, and claimed that the Assembly -- and therefore the public -- supported the CCC's ambitions to force us to be vegetarians.
This means two things.
1. The government, MPs, green wonks, civil servants, the blob, all of them, *know* that these policies are unwanted and unpopular -- that they have no mandate.
2. That they will try everything and anything to get the policies they want, all the same, and that includes acts of very obvious bad faith.
Ed Miliband and his crew and the current population of the CCC are even more determined to inflict policies on us before democracy can stop them.
This is bad for us, and it is bad for UK farmers.
Here is a video I made about it in 2020.