In one sense it's correct that the young, highly online rw types are all talk no action, but there's also a timeframe issue.
If you control for the social compassion heatmap thing the difference that remains between progressive and conservative people has a lot to do with the thoughtfulness vs impulsiveness dichotomy. Not a lot of conservative people are going to take leaps of faith without first putting all their ducks in a row. This takes time, a lot of it more often than not.
I think you *could* bring back some of these cheap-house bombed out villages if you were very strategic about *where* exactly it was and didn't depend on it suddenly happening within just a couple of years.
There has to be some commute proximity to ...some... variety of jobs not just one or two factories, a moderate climate, and a fairly neutral (as opposed to insular) culture. And probably not a radical blue taxes state. Neither the Canadian border, nor Appalachia, nor the South will work. Ohio, Indiana, (Eastern) Iowa, Southern Michigan, and maybe some parts of Western PA might fit, in basically that order.
But moreover there has to be a lot of time for people to take it slow and make the move when they can get their ducks in a row. And the effort has to be independent of charismatic leader types that give conservatives the ick.
There are actually some unique opportunities in bombed out middle America, and personally I'm taking advantage of it very nicely, but for the most part I keep my efforts private. I don't think I'm unique in this respect either.
Once you realize that the only demographics capable of renewing the American heartland consist of immigrants and liberals, the entire "alt-right" or "MAGA" thing begins to seem like a complete dead end.
Because rhetoric about "taking America back" is cheap. And those espousing it either have the vigor and vitality required to literally, actually take the heart and soul of deepest America back and to give it new life -- or they do not.
And if they do not, their rhetoric and ideals are dead on arrival.
A meaningful movement in the direction they want to go requires a caste of exceedingly fertile and adventurous foot-soldiers or it doesn't work. Not everybody can be "taking back institutions in the metropole" or whatever (not that they're particularly good at that either). Not everybody can LARP as a country club Gordon Gecko type, or be a RW podcaster, or whatever.
People need to raise their hands and say "hell yeah I'll go to Ottumwa and make it excellent, I can do that, let's try it." They need to do this in all states, including blue states, or it doesn't work.
The entire digital right wing is worthless unless it can overcome this abject lack of energy, adventure, spirit, or can-do attitude. If it cannot, it's entirely stupid and worthless -- and by what I can tell, that's just about what all that kind of talk really is at bottom.