When people were trading fanfic in person they were getting direct engagement, enthusiasm, support.
Meanwhile, fanfic writers aren’t making fic as an academic assignment. They don’t need “advice” from you. Whether on writing, or to substitute their interpretations for yours.
This is why I don’t take some ppl seriously when they talk about “low engagement.” There was once a time fanfics were only traded IN PERSON and ppl had a ball.
Now writers are trying to compete with every viral fic on the platform—while refusing to heed writing advice, mind you.