I was skeptical about the authenticity of the quotation you attributed to Sheikh Abubakar Mahmud Gumi, because to the best of my knowledge, Sheikh Abubakar Gumi never preached such opinion.
So I took my time to consult my own copy of Sheikh Gumi's Tafsir on the verse:
๏ดฟ ููู
ูุญููู ุงูููููู ุงูุฑููุจูุง ููููุฑูุจูู ุงูุตููุฏูููุงุชู ๏ดพ
and I could not find the passage you attributed to him, particularly the portion claiming:
ยซ"ูุงุฆุฏุฉ : ู
ุนุฑูู ุฃู ุจููุน ุงูุฑุจุง ู
ููุฏุฉ ุนูู ุนููู ุงูุฃุดูุงุก ุงูุฑุจููุฉ ูุง ุนูู ููู
ูุงุ ูุฃูุฑุงู ุงูุจููู ุฃู ุงูุนู
ูุฉ ุงูู
ุณุชุนู
ูุฉ ุงูููู
ููู
ููุง ูู ุงูุจููู ู
ู ุงูุฃู
ูุงู ูุฅู ูุงูุช ุชุณุชุนู
ู ููุฃุซู
ุงูุ ููู ู
ุจูุน ุซู
ูู ูููุณ ูู ุซู
ูู ุฑุจููุงู. ูุนูู ูุฐุง ูููุงุฆุฏ ุงูุจููู ุฃุฌูุฑ. ูุงููู ุฃุนูู
."ยป
This statement is not a minor detail in your article. It is one of the central pillars upon which your entire argument rests. Therefore, it is only fair that you provide clear evidence that Sheikh Abubakar Gumi actually said it.
Kindly provide:
1. The exact volume and page number of the Tafsir.
2. A clear photograph or screenshot of the original page.
3. The complete Arabic text as it appears in the book, without additions or omissions.
If the quotation genuinely exists, then producing the page should be straightforward and will immediately settle the matter.
However, if you cannot produce the page, then serious concerns arise regarding the attribution. It is not permissible to place words in the mouth of a scholar, especially in matters as grave as ribฤ, and then build an entire argument upon those words.
The scholars have long warned:
ยซู
ู ุจุฑูุฉ ุงูุนูู
ุนุฒูู ุฅูู ูุงุฆููยป
"Part of the blessing of knowledge is attributing it correctly to its source."
And Abdullah ibn al-Mubarak said:
ยซุงูุฅุณูุงุฏ ู
ู ุงูุฏููยป
"The chain of attribution is part of the religion."
We are discussing a matter that Allah and His Messenger ๏ทบ treated with the utmost seriousness. Therefore, academic integrity and honesty demand that every quotation be verifiable.
Until the source is produced, the quotation remains unsubstantiated. And if the foundation of an argument is shown to be unreliable, then it is only natural that the conclusions built upon it will also be viewed with skepticism.
So let us begin there:
Please show us the page in Sheikh Abubakar Mahmud Gumi's Tafsir from which this quotation was taken.
If the quotation is authentic, we will acknowledge it.
If it is not, then the readers deserve to know that you falsely ascribe the statement to Sheikh Abubakar Gumi so as to give credence to your own opinion and that of your likes.
ูุงููู ุงูู
ุณุชุนุงู.