It’s rare for the powerful to act in the interest of people who aren’t. They act to keep what they have. Most of what looks like principle, up close, is positioning.
On Friday the US government ordered
@AnthropicAI to pull Fable 5 and Mythos, its two most capable models, 3 days after launch. The stated reason was national security: a jailbreak the Commerce Secretary flagged in a letter that, by Anthropic’s account, named no specifics. Anthropic called it a misunderstanding and disabled the models worldwide to comply.
Now read that against what came before it. Anthropic had refused to let Claude be used for mass domestic surveillance and autonomous weapons. The Pentagon then called the company a “supply chain risk” and cancelled a $200M contract. State, Treasury and HHS are dropping Claude. The Senate just cleared Gemini, ChatGPT and Copilot for use. Claude wasn’t on the list.
So: a company that said no to two things the government wanted, and a national security concern that appeared 72 hours after its best product shipped, while every competitor walked straight through the door.
Maybe the jailbreak is real. Models that can find software vulnerabilities are a genuine problem. But “this is a security risk” and “this company stopped being useful to us” can both be true, and only one of them gets said out loud.
That’s where I’d start. Not with the press release, but with who loses if this product wins, and what they can reach for to slow it down. National security is a convenient thing to reach for. Hard to argue with, easy to misuse.
#Fable5 #Mythos