I have spent the better part of a decade running a Shopify brand. In that time I have made plenty of mistakes worth describing, but the most expensive one was simple. For too long I treated the email list as a marketing channel. It was not. It was the business. And once I understood that, everything else became easier to think about.
Here is what I mean.
A marketing channel is something you rent. Meta rents you attention for as long as you pay them. Google rents you intent for as long as you bid. TikTok rents you reach for as long as the algorithm favors you. Every one of those arrangements ends the moment the rent stops. The list, by contrast, is yours. It does not require permission. It does not get rate-limited. It does not change the rules on you in the middle of a quarter.
The lesson that took me years to absorb is that the businesses worth building are the ones that own their distribution. Not rent it. Own it. The list is the only marketing asset I have ever encountered that actually meets that test.
The second mistake I made was assuming list growth was a tactic. Pop-ups. Lead magnets. Discount codes. The kind of thing you set up once and check off. That framing produced a list that grew the way most lists grow. Slowly, then plateaued, then forgotten.
What actually moves the number is the inversion. You stop asking how to grow the list and start asking what would make someone want to stay on it. Once you answer that honestly, the work becomes obvious. You stop sending campaigns to feed the calendar. You start sending them when you actually have something worth saying. You build a community around the product because community is the thing that compounds. You treat every subscriber as a person you owe something to, not a number on a dashboard.
At Fresh Chile we now have over a million subscribers, a 36,000 person community, and a 40-50% repeat customer rate. None of it came from a clever tactic. All of it came from getting the foundation right and then waiting long enough for it to compound.
This Friday, June 12, I am presenting at
@CommerceRound The Retention Roadshow in Austin.
The talk is on list growth. The exact playbook.
@ecomchasedimond ,
@iamshackelford , and
@RytisLauris from
@omnisend are also presenting in LA tomorrow if you're in the area.
I would love to meet you in person if you're in Austin.
@yojimmykim gave me 5 free tickets.
Use code CHRISVIP at:
commerceroundtable.com/roads…