Are We a Christian Nation?
Recently, one of our gubernatorial candidates declared that America is a “Christian Nation.” Then, on September 28, after a gruesome attack on a Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints congregation in Grand Blanc, Michigan — an attack that killed four worshippers, injured eight others, and left children scarred for life — he followed it with an X post saying, “They aren’t Christian.” Authorities reported the gunman rammed a truck into the church, opened fire during Sunday worship, and set the building ablaze.
I know how the dehumanization process works.
I was a soldier. I was trained to identify an enemy, to separate “us” from “them,” and to understand how people are taught to hate before they are taught to kill. Before violence comes permission. Before permission comes othering. Before othering comes the language that says those people are not really like us, not really one of us, not really worthy of the same sympathy, dignity, or protection.
That is why this matters.
To say America is a “Christian Nation,” and then use the aftermath of a church massacre to declare that your wounded, grieving neighbors “aren’t Christian,” is not a statement of faith. It is a declaration of exclusion. It is a political use of Christianity that forgets the command to love your neighbor, mourn with those who mourn, and protect the innocent.
I am not here to settle theological disputes between denominations. That is not the job of government, and it is not the purpose of the American republic. The moment politicians start deciding which believers count as “real Christians,” they are no longer defending Christianity. They are weaponizing it.
America is not a theocracy.
The United States is a constitutional republic. It is a creedal nation built on the principles of life, liberty, property, the pursuit of happiness, equal justice under law, and the God-given rights of every person. Our Constitution does not require every citizen to share the same church. It requires government to protect the right of every citizen to worship freely, speak freely, live freely, and be treated equally under the law.
That is the genius of America.
A Christian can believe this nation was deeply shaped by Christian moral tradition. I do. A Christian can believe our rights come from God, not government. I do. A Christian can believe faith belongs in the public square. I do.
But no Christian should look at children watching their parents bleed in a sanctuary and decide the urgent thing to say is, “They aren’t Christian.”
That is not leadership.
That is not Idaho.
And it is not the kind of spirit I want anywhere near the governor’s office, the U.S. Senate, or any position of public trust.
If we are going to speak of Christian government, then start with Christian conduct: mercy, humility, courage, truth, protection of the innocent, and love of neighbor.
Because a nation is not made Christian by slogans.
It is judged by how it treats the wounded, the grieving, the stranger, the widow, the orphan, and the neighbor whose doctrine may differ from our own.
America is a constitutional republic.
And the job of every public servant is not to decide which Americans count.
It is to defend the rights, dignity, and liberty of them all.