R Street Institute Fellow, Tech & Innovation. Opinions and puns are my own. @jgwithrow@techpolicy.social

Joined April 2011
126 Photos and videos
Josh Withrow retweeted
John has it exactly right. Selling out digital liberty and free speech in exchange for a few crumbs of limited state AI preemption is not a good deal. Wrote about that yesterday with @JGWithrow: rstreet.org/commentary/ai-pr…
Just so we're clear, trading preemption of some state AI laws for federal bills like KOSA, NO FAKES, GUARD Act, or ASAA is a bad deal for free speech online.
2
4
19
1,211
Josh Withrow retweeted
The bill quite literally sets different rules for certain companies based purely on them being more successful. In no way does it make companies “play by the same rules.” A company below the thresholds set in this legislation can do everything it bans.
Big Tech abuses their market power 2stifle competition restrict consumer choice raise prices online American consumers pay the price Sen Klobuchar&I introd American Innovation& Choice Online Act 2ensure the worlds largest digital platforms play by the same rules as everyone else
2
5
18
874
Josh Withrow retweeted
This bill (AICOA) really gets me fired up b/c it’s basically a bill of attainder targeting a couple of firms for being way too good at doing things lots of other companies do but don’t do as well. It’s the break Tom Brady and Michael Jordan’s legs of competition policy. 👎
In the middle of an affordability crisis, these Senators are laser focused on… banning Amazon Prime and Google Maps. Copying the homework of the overseers of Europe’s stagnant economy.
1
3
20
1,942
Bad ideas never die in Washington DC: everyone's favorite bill to punish Big Tech for making conveniently integrated products that consumers love to use has, somehow, returned. My statement about it is up on R Street's website:
New - @SenAmyKlobuchar and @ChuckGrassley have reintroduced their re-worked American Innovation and Choice Online Act tonight.
1
6
20
3,768
Particularly crazy to revive AICOA after watching the EU enforce similar self-preferencing bans and all European consumers have to show for it are annoying choice screens, less functional search engines, and delayed access to the latest AI tools. rstreet.org/commentary/reint…
1
1
199
Josh Withrow retweeted
As I covered in April, while age verification laws are often well intentioned, they have broad unintended consequences. In the UK, for example, OSA’s stringent requirements have left companies opting to overcensor due to lawsuit worries. Similar legislation in the US would have similar consequences x.com/edtarnowski/status/204…

1
6
24
1,908
Josh Withrow retweeted
Empower parents, not government. Stop this nonsense highlighted by @TheFIREorg 🔥🔥🔥
We’re one bad deal away from the era of online government censorship. The White House and Congress are negotiating away your rights as we speak. FIRE urges lawmakers to reject any deal that includes the Kids Online Safety Act, the NO FAKES Act, and age verification requirements.
12
31
936
RT @TaylorLorenz: Rep. Auchincloss admits on the record that the mass surveillance and censorship laws he and his ilk are seeking to pass a…
189
Josh Withrow retweeted
Parents have control now. You don’t need a law for that.
Screen time is a problem. So is the fact that Big Tech profits from exposing children to addictive content online. My App Store Accountability Act holds Big Tech accountable and puts parents back in control of what their kids are exposed to online. today.com/video/surgeon-gene…
1
38
164
3,762
Josh Withrow retweeted
New at @TOTMblog : “Artificial Intelligence, Natural Ignorance” A Hayekian perspective on AI regulation, the knowledge problem, and why policymakers should be cautious about trying to direct technological change. @andashleysays @Jeffrey_Depp truthonthemarket.com/2026/06…
3
4
159
Josh Withrow retweeted
Children should not navigate the digital world alone, which is why parents should be empowered, not government! The ASAAct is big-government policy for politicians and regulators to take the place of parents because some people don’t trust parents. Better path for government is educating parents and kids about online activity rather than pushing bad policy. Empower parents, not government!
Children should not navigate the digital world alone. The App Store Accountability Act restores parental control by requiring age verification, ensuring parental consent for app downloads, and reinforcing a parent’s role in guiding their child’s digital experience. Read more ⤵️
3
9
36
1,410
Josh Withrow retweeted
It’s baaaa-aaaack
Dear Readers: Something has been really bugging me about NO FAKES, and it's this: NO FAKES is NOT copyright, it's a straight up speech regulation that contravenes the First Amendment. coons.senate.gov/imo/media/d…

ALT Cbs No GIF by HULU

1
4
395
Josh Withrow retweeted
Two things can simultaneously be true about this new AI security executive order: 1) This represents a reasonable governance arrangement for frontier model security and its oversight, at least when compared with the far more intrusive ideas floated earlier, like the pre-vetting of models via a formal government licensing regime (aka, “FDA for AI”). 2) This represent as significant win for the military-industrial complex and the continuing fiction of “voluntarism” surrounding its inner workings. Thanks to open-ended EOs like this, the new growing AI-industrial complex will further concentrate power around AI – in both government and industry – and lead to more avenues for public officials to exert control over not just model security, but potentially many other aspects of algorithmic development and use, including content-related matters. After all, “security” is in the eye of the beholder (and future administrations and officials).
3
9
51
5,572
Josh Withrow retweeted
🚨🚨 North Carolina Age Verification Bill Hearing Tomorrow AM! 🚨🚨 This bill is unconstitutional and would negatively impact NC consumers' online experience. A quick🧵:
6
86
176
9,552
Josh Withrow retweeted
more equity stakes insanity on the way. Crony computational capitalism via "equity stakes" isn't real capitalism at all. It is just a softer version of Chinese-style central planning. It's fundamentally anti-free market and un-American. This is also how big government gets its hooks into the AI economy in an even bigger way and comes to influence information systems at a deep level, and along multiple dimensions. The power of the purse is a formidable regulatory tool, especially once Uncle Sam is a formal co-owner of your business. I especially can't wait to see how Gavin Newsom or the next Dem president uses these equity stakes to impose a mass DEI agenda on every company who cut these deals with Trump Admin. Hope you like a slice of social justice pie with your your equity steak, er.. stake. Oh, the irony of it all!
4
12
33
4,221
Josh Withrow retweeted
On behalf of @ITIFdc, @JosephVConiglio warns the @EU_Commission that its draft measures specifying Android's interoperability requirements under the DMA would threaten user privacy and discourage Google from continuing to invest and innovate in the Android ecosystem. itif.org/publications/2026/0…
4
9
428
Josh Withrow retweeted
It is unconstitutional for the FCC to take regulatory action based on the content of broadcast speech.
For the latest on the Media and Democracy Project's effort to challenge the broadcast licenses of @FOX29philly read more here. fcc.gov/ecfs/document/105148…
1
216
Josh Withrow retweeted
The hearing at the Senate Judiciary Committee on "From the Courtroom to Congress: Why Landmark Social Media Verdicts Demand Federal Action to Protect Kids Online" just ended, after 2 hours of mainly propping up two proposals: KOSA and reform/repeal Section 230. 🧵Some thoughts:
2
20
28
3,438
Josh Withrow retweeted
The implication here, that European policymakers could end up banning VPNs, is rather chilling. Under the cover of targeting big tech, lots of our digital rights and protections in Europe are being eroded. It's a major problem and more people should be fighting against it.
Virtual private networks #VPN are increasingly used to bypass online age verification. Protecting children online is a priority, with new rules being implemented requiring a minimum age for access to some services Read👉 link.europa.eu/FGfr6C #DSA @EP_Justice @FZarzalejos
Community note
According to the University of Michigan research paper "Multi-perspective study of VPN users and VPN providers," 82.1% used VPNs "to protect myself from various threats/adversaries." No research shows that VPNs would be increasingly used to bypass online age verification. censoredplanet.org/papers/VPN-Sur…
7
25
1,081
"...the pattern is familiar from earlier moral panics over comic books, rock music, and video games. Each was sincerely felt. Each rested on weak social science amplified by strong public emotion. Each produced a policy that aged poorly."
New from @AdamOmaryPhD and me in light a variety of state and federal proposals for age verification for AI. The reality is that when it comes to chatbots and teen mental health, it's way more complicated and the wrong regulation could make things worse cato.org/blog/what-ai-chatbo…
1
3
267