If a person said to me "I want to move to rural America" I would tell them to locate near a college that is likely to survive.
Property won't really be all that more expensive than otherwise, and it will be 100x easier socially.
You probably don't want "real" rural America!
Collegetows are America's truly unique and superior life environments, specially for full-grown adults. Not NYC. So many people that are miserable trying and failing to make it in NYC would be so much happier in Ithaca.