Family lawyer, emeritus professor, Executive Director, Publica @PublicaAus; one of the Jesus crowd.

Joined November 2023
6 Photos and videos
This is a significant new decision concerning the provision of toilets in a primary school. The judge found that the school 's arrangements amounted to indirect discrimination against girls because, after toileting, they had to wash their hands in a common area shared with boys.
The Scottish Court of Session has just ruled that providing multi-user unisex toilets in a primary school amounted to indirect sex discrimination against female pupils. scotcourts.gov.uk/media/mv5d…
1
2
167
The decision does not rest upon any peculiarities of Scottish or British law. The reasoning would be equally applicable to the Sex Discrimination Act in Australia.
1
2
79
Other aspects of the decision are specific to Scottish regulations but not the finding in relation to indirect discrimination
50
The Giggle case raises a fundamental issue of societal organisation, akin to whether the State will allow private property. Trans rights need to be accommodated where possible, but not at the expense of ignoring basic differences between sexes.@salltweets @aytchellesse @DoNoHarm79
I posted this elsewhere but it bears repeating: I’m a gay left-wing atheist, and Albanese is my local member as well as my PM. I’m pretty much a lifelong Labor voter. I’m certainly no right wing religious zealot. Yet Labor lost my vote last Friday. I wrote to the PM about this issue and got a passive-aggressive response from a staffer that talked about Liberals and tax policy, and didn’t even address my complaint. It told me everything I needed to know. A party that can’t stand up for simple dignity and safety for women and girls is a party that I cant trust on any issue.
4
2
7
1,001
A trans adult says trans issues should not be taught in schools. "All you do is confuse children by essentially marketing a way to be special and get attention." The marketing of trans-identification in primary schools must stop.
I don’t think children should be exposed to transsexuality until they are much older. It’s shouldn’t be in the schools. It shouldn’t be on television. No one needed to tell me I wanted to be a girl. For an actual trans child, it’s all they’re ever gonna think about. All you do is confuse children by essentially marketing a way to be special and get attention. Some of these kids will play around with gender presentation. Parents should stop that bullying instantly. Give kids space to figure out who they are. But the reality is, we cannot sort out the actual trans girls from the gay boys until they are like 12 and puberty starts onsetting. I would not allow my child to change pronouns or name before then.
10
165
Singapore is the latest jurisdiction to examine the evidence and to ban puberty blockers and hormones for minors. Yet Australian gender clinicians persist in denying there is an issue. open.substack.com/pub/gender…
6
50
177
2,247
The tragic account of a young gay boy who was told with certainty by his medical specialists and others that he was 'born in the wrong body'. Now he is in a body that doesn't function the way that either a male or female body should. thefp.com/p/i-de-transitione…
1
2
5
152
This is a fascinating article by Michael Biggs and a colleague. Michael has done so much to expose falsehoods and misunderstandings about transgender issues in Britain. What this article shows clearly is that, while numbers are fortunately low, rather more transgender persons are perpetrators of homicide than are the victims of it. Yet you would not know this from media reporting, which has bought the line that transgender people are disproportionately murder victims. A must -read article correcting yet another misunderstanding.
Who are "the most vulnerable in society"? New paper by Michael Biggs and Ace North: "It analyzes all homicides involving transgender people in Britain from 2000 to 2025. Victims were outnumbered by perpetrators, even excluding those who declared a transgender identity after imprisonment. Almost all cases involved natal males identifying as transwomen. The victim-perpetrator ratio among these individuals closely resembles that for males overall and differs markedly from that for females." papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.…
4
38
139
3,800
Australians should welcome Dr Beth Upton as we welcome so many other migrants who join our caring professions. Australia is the land of the fresh start. Dr Upton needs this after the adverse publicity of the case in Scotland. Dr Upton clearly said some silly things in the witness box under pressure. We all make mistakes. All doctors understand that there are some conditions that only women have and some that only men have. Dr Upton, I am sure, does not believe that one can self-identify into female medical conditions! However, the warm Australian welcome has to be conditioned on Dr Upton allowing women, including nurses, their private spaces and respecting the fact that some female patients will not be comfortable being examined by a transfemale doctor. These are small concessions to ask, so that all rights are equally respected.@AusHumanRights; @RachaelWongAus;@rachelbaxendale.
809
30
251
89,940
This post has clearly generated some strong reactions! I understand that; but look at it another way. A young doctor, just starting out, has been so strongly and publicly criticised- for good reasons - that they choose to move to the other side of the world. What place is there in our society for grace, forgiveness and tolerance? If a professional, who has had this bad a start to their career, doesn't learn from what has happened when given a new start in another country, that is on them; but I don't think any of us really want to live in a society that doesn't offer any opportunity for fresh starts. The other point is that I expect there are a number of other transgender medics in Australia - born here. So we have to work out accommodations and compromises that, so far as possible, respect all rights and allow people their dignity. For the most part, we can choose our doctors. The trashing of women's rights has been a shocking aspect of the recent 'trans rights' movement; but we mustn't trash others' rights or trample upon people's dignity, in the process of correcting those errors.
292
3
39
41,419
Part of the tragedy of @Jilliantweeting's three year suspension (so far) is that she has largely not been able to practise her profession as a child and adolescent psychiatrist when there is a mountain of need. This is shameful, @childhealthqld; @TimNichollsMP.
2
18
787
Yes. It is not about protecting patients. It is about punishment for not towing the line - a line which has now become discredited internationally.
1
6
509
If you want to teach at the University of Auckland, you’ll be pleased to know that it provides a safe, inclusive, and equitable environment for LGBTQIATakatāpuiMVPFAFF . Any suggestions what this stands for?
5
1
10
825
Patrick Parkinson retweeted
UPDATE ON IMPORTANT NEW FINLAND STUDY | Professor Kaltiala has responded to criticism of the Finnish study, which found that mental health may get worse after young people undergo medical gender transition. One critique of the study argues that psychiatric appointments are part and parcel of the gender-transition process in Finland and therefore may not point to serious psychiatric morbidity. In their paper, Professor Kaltiala and her colleagues acknowledged the limitation that their study could not analyse in detail why these patients needed psychiatric services. Asked about this issue, she told me that the healthcare register data used for the study included diagnoses and in-patient periods but not treatment nor information about a patient’s problems related to family life, romantic relationships or work. However, Professor Kaltiala said the young people seen by specialised psychiatric services in her country would have “severe disorders”. These services were focused on “those really in need”, consistent with national criteria for health equity. “In Finland, you do not get admitted to specialist-level services if you don’t have mental disorders at all or [have only] mild disorders and problems,” she said. “Primary-level services are available for needs related to milder disorders and psychosocial difficulties.” She said the gender-referred youth in the new study were much more likely than matched controls to have a history of severe mental disorders, often dating back some years before they reached the gender clinic. “Thus, many developed feelings of gender dysphoria in the context of severe disorders,” she said. “Severe mental disorders during adolescence generally have potential to complicate identity development. It rather seems that feelings of gender dysphoria are sometimes secondary to severe mental disorders.” If it were the other way around, and the mental disorders were secondary to the dysphoria, those disorders would be “expected to subside with medical gender reassignment”, according to the Dutch treatment protocol adopted internationally, she said. But this did not happen in the new Finnish study. Instead, the need for specialist psychiatric services—and therefore the scale of serious mental disorders—increased after medical transition, as the study by Professor Kaltiala and her colleagues reported. Updated news report ⬇️ open.substack.com/pub/gender…

52
612
2,065
218,632
I guess they didn't teach these people about control groups in their gender studies degree.
That Finnish study… the one that everyone’s talking about…
Community note
Control groups let researchers compare a group to the general population, to establish a baseline and evaluate whether rates of issues are abnormal. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10… In the Finnish studies, it showed persistent high needs pre- and post-referral, not clearly reduced by medical transition. onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/ap…
1
20
587
In a world where true forgiveness is all too rare, the message of Easter is that we can be forgiven for the worst of sins, if only we accept that forgiveness from the crucified and risen Lord Jesus.
1
3
5
240
WPATH leader acknowledges that children are in the driving seat in being allowed to choose irreversible medical interventions. open.substack.com/pub/benrya…

2
12
918
Patrick Parkinson retweeted
It is about time those of us in progressive politics owned up to our failures. ·       We argued for social justice for all and ended up arguing it should only be for a favoured few identity groups. ·       We argued for women’s rights and ended up arguing men could be women and could occupy women’s spaces. ·       We argued for same-sex marriage and ended up with saying there are no sex-based rights. ·       We argued for renewable energy and ended up allowing giant, multinational energy companies to bulldoze thousands of hectares of our precious, high biodiversity forests for wind farms. ·       We argued for free speech and ended up by practising cancel culture. ·       We argued for multiculturalism and ended up believing that criticism of the practices of a minority culture is, necessarily, racism. ·       We argued that imperialism should be combated and ended up believing only US imperialism causes authoritarianism and repression.
124
372
1,810
54,973