We spent several hundred thousand US$ on failed experiments. Here’s why it was money well spent:
Humans have spent over 150 years adding carbon dioxide to the atmosphere, and we have barely started removing it—we are still in the learning phase.
For example, with enhanced rock weathering, we don’t know what exactly happens in the soil when we spread rock dust on fields. Figuring this out is important, yet it will require many new experiments.
When you try things nobody has done before, you’re bound to hit roadblocks.
In 2021 we were developing our first experiment to test the effectiveness of advanced rock weathering on croplands, and after 12 months the results simply did not match our projections.
We hit the first roadblock. We simply could not show that we removed carbon.
Okay… so… now what?
We set up a second, more ambitious project by 7-folding the number of experiments, adding hundreds of sensors and moving into a more controlled environment. After 12 more months, the data told us that we again did not remove carbon from the atmosphere.
We checked the data and the experiments again and again to find out if we were either measuring the data incorrectly or if the weathering process actually didn’t work as expected. But we weren’t doing it wrong!
At this second roadblock, instead of giving up, we scaled up again.
We ran an even more ambitious project—now with 400 different pots as we created the world’s largest greenhouse EW experiment along the way—and finally over the next 24 months we found some of the 400 tests worked exactly as originally expected.
Our methods were never the issue, the problem was always the unlucky soil/rock combination we used in our two original experiments. We had made a very unfortunate choice.
We failed. Or did we?
We found that EW doesn’t work under certain conditions. That’s valuable information to have as we plan an even bigger experiment for this year.
We failed fast, we did not give up, and we iterated further. Now we are much closer to impactful projects. By failing obviously and quickly, we’re closer to ultimate success.
Stay tuned for a white paper documentation of the entire project, coming soon!