I've been wanting to write this for many, many years, because it's something I've always been curious about. Now it's finally here. Thanks, @davidedgarwolftheguardian.com/football/202…
Fully agree. One possible middle ground would be referee chief giving a statement on Mondays to clarify points of law/procedure. But any interview or press conference would create more problems than it would solve
A lot to unpack in that Wolves v Leeds game. Lopetegui has a case on the penalty, but always a red for Jonny and not a foul on Traore before Leeds 4th goal. Nice to see a referee stick by their original decision after VAR recommended a review
Really messy process from Stuart Attwell. Looks like he was going to caution Ziyech for original foul so at the very least it should be a 2nd caution for the push on Royal
Yesterday was a poor day for officials in PL. But I don't think refs are 'worse' now than they used to be - at no time in football history has anyone ever claimed that the officials of the day are good. And never claim corruption when something can be explained by incompetence
The VAR review for a Uruguay penalty was not rejected for handball. It was because the referee felt Daniel Amartey got the ball.
If it had been rejected for handball, play would have restarted with a free kick to Ghana in their penalty area. It didn't. #GHAURU#FIFAWorldCup
Undoubtedly a penalty. Uruguay players did well to make Ayew have to wait so long before taking it but referee needed to be stronger. He's viewed the replay so isn't changing his mind. Needs to clear the area quickly and speed up the restart.
Some offsides contain a subjective element. VAR would have told Anthony Taylor which player was in an offside position, and then he was sent to the monitor to determine whether that player was active or not #hrv#bel#FIFAWorldCup
The #ARG penalty is one that logically is a foul. Messi gets to the ball before Szczesny, and GK then clearly catches Messi in the face. However I don't think anyone expects (or wants) a penalty to be given for that.
tbf, not just bbc. And don't start on the role of asst ref and late flagging for offside. Ex.players as well, who would be apoplectic if game stopped for offside and proven to be onside
BBC commentators once again showing a complete lack of understanding of the laws. Accidental handball in lead up to a goal is only a factor if the player that scores handled it. Really isn't difficult yet they manage to get it wrong so often