Risk Analysis, Grey Zone, Fragile States, Diaspora, Canadian FP, Professional Hole Poker, P/T Boat Builder, Davos Scenarios: hegelversusmarx.substack.com

Joined January 2022
472 Photos and videos
Pinned Tweet
@steffanwatkins Most of Canada's entrenched pro-US bureaucrats are oblivious to the harm being done on their watch. My analysis shows that their ignorance is a key indicator of US grey zone success. Denial is part of that. peacediplomacy.org/2026/01/2…
2
1
189
David Carment retweeted
Western funding, intelligence, and weapons systems shield Kyiv from the full geopolitical consequences of its actions. Open-ended support creates a situation where the primary risk of war with a nuclear-armed state is borne by Western allies rather than Ukraine.
1
24
David Carment retweeted
Washington can unilaterally alter the terms of the bilateral relationship at any moment based on its own domestic political whims—whether through protectionist trade measures, extraterritorial sanctions, or sudden regulatory shifts. Prove me wrong.
1
42
David Carment retweeted
If a sovereign nation cannot independently repair, update, or supply its own primary defence assets without foreign clearance and technical data keys, it does not possess operational sovereignty. It possesses a leased capability.
1
2
44
David Carment retweeted
By focusing exclusively on conventional, threat-based defence spending (like chasing the arbitrary 2% NATO GDP target), the establishment ignores the eroding performance indicators of the state itself.
1
42
David Carment retweeted
The pushback from the establishment doesn't dismantle my "engineered vulnerabilities" thesis; it acts as a textbook example of learned helplessness. By treating dependency as a necessity rather than a structural variable the old guard validates my socialization critique.
1
1
59
David Carment retweeted
Its coverage of global affairs is appalling despite some strong reporters like Dyer and Raffi. Their "At Issue" panel and PNP are biased flag waving platforms for entrenched old guard viewpoints...
1
32
David Carment retweeted
@steffanwatkins Most of Canada's entrenched pro-US bureaucrats are oblivious to the harm being done on their watch. My analysis shows that their ignorance is a key indicator of US grey zone success. Denial is part of that. peacediplomacy.org/2026/01/2…
2
1
189
David Carment retweeted
Today in Haaretz there is an article accusing Israel of being a terrorist state (plus committing crimes against humanity). It was not written by a Marxist member of the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine. It was written by former Israeli PM Ehud Olmert.
138
2,373
5,752
124,354
David Carment retweeted
This is Israeli columnist for Bari Weiss’s Free Press is calling for Israel to “Dust off the nukes. Maybe test one.” Insane, unhinged, extremist stuff from a supposedly centrist publication run by a woman now in command of CBS News and soon CNN too.
Welp, I think we're done here. Trump himself is now saying he buckled under the pressure of Hormuz. It's as bad as it could possibly be. He's saying aloud that Iran can have anything it wants because America can't afford the staring contest. If this is his own explanation in his own words, then the fact that the sanctions relief is front-loaded...suddenly becomes important. The fact that the inspections regime that will verify compliance will be negotiated by an American side that has already admitted defeat, that needs this more than the opponent needs it...is now significant. And the fact that the proxy system is now recognized as legitimate by the United States -- is suddenly exactly the disaster you feared it might be. And the fact that America has declared aloud that it's not actually capable of imposing its will even in the world's most vital energy chokepoints, causing its allies in the Gulf to already begin to seek a new accommodation with Iran -- makes all of this worse than Obama and worse than the JCPOA. Remember: the great unfixable flaw of the JCPOA that none of its boosters ever had a good answer for was that it merely kicked the can down the road. It solved nothing. Trump's deal, as of this moment, is not even close to accomplishing so much. "Iran never won a war and never lost a negotiation," Trump famously said of Obama's deal (as a reporter reminded him at today's press conference). Ironic that the Iranians would win a negotiation most spectacularly against a man who styles himself the greatest negotiator to ever grace the White House. So what does it all mean? It means that in the coming years, nuclear programs will sprout like mushrooms after the rain throughout the Middle East. It means that many nations will now build out new and larger ballistic missile arsenals. It means that the state system will give way before the march of the region's transnational ideological axes. Minorities will again be trampled, new wars will be fought by stronger states to dominate the power vacuums within weaker ones. You're thinking of Israel in Lebanon -- but that's just a specific campaign against a specific enemy. Think Turkey, which right now occupies a region of Syria vastly larger than Israel's presence in Lebanon. Think heightened Iranian support for the Houthis in Yemen and a new influx of money and guns to the different sides in Libya. It means, in other words, that we will have a few more wars to fight, a few more technologies to invent to deal with this new age of cheap missiles and drones -- and also of supersonic Chinese missiles bearing nuclear warheads that Iran will eventually, inevitably, be capable of deploying against us. And it didn't have to be this bad. (And maybe, when he's heard all the criticism, it won't be.) He could have left something, anything, to concede later. He could have kept the Iranians a little bit in the dark, just a smidgen, as to just how defeated America feels. Israel's position in all this is simple, and more or less unchanged from last week. America gave us more than we had a right to ask for. But we may be going it alone from here out. Dust off the nukes. Maybe test one somewhere far away from anywhere. Quadruple the interceptor production lines, double the size of the Mossad and the Air Force. And no, don't let Hezbollah breathe, not for a second. It's the 1960s again. And Israel will have to defeat a couple more enemies before it can once again eke out a few decades of peace.
74
568
2,672
147,958
David Carment retweeted
If the U.S. wants to get its way, then it’ll have to do something it has long avoided: force Israel to back down using America’s extraordinary leverage over the country responsiblestatecraft.org/us…
2
11
19
346
David Carment retweeted
Adam Schiff is angry that Trump "capitulated" to Iran and tons of neocons and Israel Firsters are so shocked in response: "Oh wow, I can't believe I agree with Schiff." The Democratic Party is not anti-war, nor anti-Israel, nor "soft on Iran." Those are idiot partisan narratives fed to you by Fox News and its ilk. The Dem Party is filled with AIPAC-funded candidates and those who revere Israel above all. The Senate Dem leader Chuck Schumer is both of those things and favors war with Iran. Schiff is the same. Of course Schiff's views align with Israel's and he wants more war with Iran every bit as much as Ben Shapiro and Mike Huckabee. Endless wars, financing Israel, and regime-change wars in the Middle East have been a fully bipartisan passion for decades.
Wow. Iran gets sanctions relief, the release of frozen funds, the ability to export oil, and a $300 billion reconstruction fund. The U.S. gets a reiteration of the vague promise Iran won’t develop a nuke. Hard to imagine a more thorough capitulation.
213
1,579
7,097
265,783
David Carment retweeted
Trump again denounces Israel for its indifference to (non-Jewish) human life by destroying apartment buildings in Beirut for no reason. He never quite seemed to care in Gaza. Trump's new-ish son-in-law is Lebanese Christian. His dad is a Trump adviser. Probably a factor.
🚨 TRUMP: “I think [Israel] could do better … I'm not saying they shouldn't protect themselves. I'm saying when two drones are shot into the desert and drop harmlessly, you don't have to knock down buildings in Beirut. They could behave better…”
117
647
3,825
156,042
David Carment retweeted
Is it normal for Israel to “take more territory” @Reuters or it is ILLEGAL OCCUPATION?
15
596
1,475
21,554
David Carment retweeted
They are too scared to criticize Trump, so now its "the Vance peace deal".
Getting Lebanon included in the Vance peace deal was an Iranian objective, not the U.S. - and one the U.S. initially resisted when the ceasefire was announced. To spin this as an American achievement is Orwellian.
17
340
2,167
99,372
David Carment retweeted
Self described Lebanese Zionist @HagarChemali attacks Trump from the neocon center for potentially obstructing Israel’s ethnic cleansing campaign in Lebanon This warmongering Israeli plant served in the Obama and Bush II admins

53
667
2,414
46,615
David Carment retweeted
Thinking again about those 150 Iranian sailors who were slaughtered on their way back from India for absolutely nothing.
220
4,059
27,580
573,883
RT @DonDavies: An attack by Trump Netanyahu that violates international law on a fabricated pretext, killed innocent civilians & children…
111
David Carment retweeted
These are the hostages that U.S. media ignore.
Israel's top court rejects appeal for release of Gaza doctor held without charge haaretz.com/israel-news/isra…
3
673
1,819
21,296