Aesthetically, I think UP should be given to Wisconsin, but politically, I'd hate it, as Wisconsin would become the most frustrating swing state.
WI UP:
2016 Prez: R 1.6
2020 Prez: R 0.2
2024 Prez: R 1.7
MI without UP:
2016 Prez: D 0.4
2020 Prez: D 3.38
2024 Prez: R 0.85