Ah, the disavow tool. You already know how I feel about this. :) Well,
@CyrusShepard just ran another experiment where he disavowed every link to his site. He did this before, but now did it again. So what happened? Nothing. Literally nothing.
Note, Cyrus covers how link count in GSC dropped heavily after disavowing, only to surge back, but that was a bug impacting many sites. Barry covered that in several posts (and I covered it too on X).
So why didn't Cyrus drop at all rankings-wise? Hard to say for sure, but could be a number of things. E.g. Google continuing to count the link signals even though the links were disavowed, maybe Google didn't recrawl all of the links yet (I doubt that's the case but possible), maybe it reflects the decreasing power of links overall (although he nuked ALL links). Only Google really knows... Muahahaha.
Regardless, please stop disavowing links unless you really need to. E.g. you have a manual action, you participated in some link scheme, etc. And like I have explained before, I truly believe Google will remove the Disavow Tool, and maybe soon. It's really a waste of time for 99.99% of site owners.
zyppy.com/seo/google-disavow…