Dear
@CommunityNotes and
@CNviolations,
Here is my first impression. I cut my teeth on
@Wikipedia within months of
@lsanger having co-founded it (yes,
@jimmy_wales is co-founder, but he was still thinking transactionally—he hadn't ruled out selling out
wikipedia.org for
wikipedia.com). I know what it means to make an internet property more valuable with my donated labor. I have also a invested considerable time as a
#GoogleGuide already. I use it all the time, and I find the work satisfying. The question I am asking myself now is, "Do I want to give away even a minute of my time to this program, Community Notes (CN)?" I carry considerable baggage about
@ElonMusk (EM) abandoning the Twitter brand. I am extremely suspicious about his motives to achieve world domination with his
@X brand. Why on earth would I want to work to make this platform better? I do not feel loyalty to this community. I am already having to pay $3 a month for minimal premium features. I was never even offered to contribute to CN until I started paying. Pardon my bluntness. I say this to shock you into attention:
x.com is a whore, a soulless immortal whore. You, the staff, are the survivors from EM's hostile takeover. Surely you have personal motives for renting your brains to your corporate masters. I am going to need some convincing. Can you give me some personal connections to the human beings donating their labor to Community Notes?
Since I have the space, here is my
@claudeai prompt: Put the concept of making corporations' platforms better into context. I am satisfied with my relationship with Google as an unpaid Google Guide. I make Google Maps better for everyone. I use it and I benefit from it. However, I have reservations about doing the same for
x.com as a member privileged to rate and, eventually, to write Community Notes (CN). For historical context, I am a strong support of the Hacker Ethic. I have contributed to FLOSS over the years (only a token amount, but I have some cred), and my proudest achievement is the early work I did on Wikipedia—back when it was powered by MeatballWiki! My contributions, and those of others during that time, are not easy to findy anymore. Yet, I take great pride in what I accomplished. Fast forward 26 years. Do I start from scratch at
x.com to do the same? This time, I only enrich Elon Musk and the shareholders. Indications are strong that the parent company, SpaceX, will go public this year. That’s another complication. I have a complicated relationship with Reddit. I am a non-anonymous Redditor. I have only token karma, and I own only one share of
$RDDT, but I am pleased that my share has increased 254% in value! If I donate my labor to CN, it would be partly motivated by my desire to contribute to an increase in my own wealth once shares of SpaceX are for sale.
I asked Grok the same.
Here are links to both convos:
-
claude.ai/share/83c9cc2c-dcb…
-
x.com/i/grok/share/d6f751d3d…
cc
@lsanger @svchekanov (because you have both chosen to pay for Premium features, and I respect your opinions, if you wish to chime in)