Filter
Exclude
Time range
-
Near
Replying to @SupriyaShrinate
They asked us to use public transport but here is the condition of public transportation... 🫡 #Neetpapar #pmsreality
2
Show me PMS clients who by investing in various PMS products in the market have become MULTIMILLIONAIRES!😋 PMS sab MAYA, CLIENT ke haath kuch nahi aata, bus client ka BANK BALANCE chale jata PMS provider ke JEB main! 🤣🤣 @Vaidyajii1 @talwaredge @sreekotnur #pmsreality
AUM of 12000 cr in June 2023 to an AUM of 2500 cr in May 2026 is the real Sankatkaal sir. Saurabh Mukherjea says we are in Sankatkaal but his PMS clients have been in Sankatkaal ever since they gave their money into the hands of Marcellus Investment Managers. His main Scheme Consistent Compounders Portfolio benchmarked against Nifty 50 fell short of even Nifty 50 returns over 1 year, 2 years, 3 years, 5 years, and since Inception. So are his other schemes. His client base fell from 7000 clients to 2133 clients in last 30 odd months. AUM fell from a massive 10000 cr to 2515 cr in the last 30 months. Marcellus has seen negative net flows every month. He is an amazing salesman but clients have seen through his inability to generate returns. Our Media houses dont question him because they need each other to scratch each other’s back. Its a shame. Retail Investors must be extremely careful when we have such a scary ecosystem built by incapable fund managers and media houses.
3
263
Basant Maheshwari and Saurabh Mukherjee's PMS: Overhyped, underperforming. Basant Maheshwari PMS - 3 Year Return: 4.63% TWRR - 5 Year Return: 1.29% TWRR BSE 500 Returns - 3 Year Return : 12.89% - 5 Year Return : 11.76% Saurabh Mukherjee's 'Rising Giants' PMS - Since Inception (Dec 2021): -1.67% Return - Benchmark (BSE 500 TRI) Return: 11.52% over the same period. Underperformed Benchmark BSE 500 indices over the same periods. High fees, low returns. Investors deserve better. #InvestSmart #PMSReality"
133
120
810
177,412
A family friend invested 28L in a “star” PMS in 2021. Today it’s 37L (~5.7% CAGR). Meanwhile, Nifty/index funds did better, yet the PMS still charged hefty annual fees. Investor took the risk. Manager took the guaranteed income. #PMSReality
173
117
893
180,521
You’re paying more for less growth and more risk. PMS providers promise high returns but come with sky-high fees (1-2% AUM performance fees) and lack of transparency. What you get: concentrated bets, higher volatility, and marketing hype. So why doesn’t SEBI act on PMS schemes that constantly underperform benchmarks? Kya yahan bhi ghoos chalti hai? 🤔 Smart investing = low-cost, diversified portfolios. Don’t fall for the noise! #PMSReality #InvestingTruth
4
2
17
3,461
In 2022, ₹65 lakhs was invested in Basant Maheshwari’s PMS. Today, it’s worth about ₹74.4 lakhs — roughly 7% annual return. Meanwhile, many mutual funds delivered 12-15% returns over the same period. And mutual funds charge much lower fees. Basant’s high fees eat into your gains without giving better performance. You pay more for less growth and more risk. This isn’t smart investing, it’s overpriced underperformance. Don’t fall for marketing hype — choose your investments wisely. #PMSReality
24
61
414
33,871
My uncle invested ₹65 lakhs in Basant Maheshwari’s PMS in 2022.
 Today, it’s worth ₹74.38 lakhs. That’s ~6.9% CAGR. Out of that ₹65L, Basant comfortably took 2% annual fees —
for underperforming FDs, mutual funds, and even Nifty index. No alpha. No outperformance. Just marketing fluff.
He made money — while investors carried the risk. This is not portfolio management.
It’s premium-priced underperformance. Wake up. Don’t get fooled by suits, books, and big talk.
#PMSReality
585
858
5,229
745,743
Basant Maheshwari and Saurabh Mukherjee's PMS: Overhyped, underperforming. Basant Maheshwari PMS ◦3-Year Return: 5.53% CAGR ◦5-Year Return: 9.21% CAGR ◦Underperformed Nifty 50 and Nifty 500 indices over the same periods Saurabh Mukherjee's 'Rising Giants' PMS ◦Since Inception (Dec 2021): -15% Return ◦Benchmark (BSE 500 TRI) Return: ~7% over the same period High fees, low returns. Investors deserve better. #InvestSmart #PMSReality"
120
217
1,423
154,782