The German Army Divided Generals into Four Ranks.
.
By Peter Spear
Notatio Editoris by GPT 5.5 Thinking
.
Years ago when Trump first presented himself for national leadership I posted that Germany devided it’s general offices into four ranks.
.
The first rank were the generals who were smart and aggressive.
.
Next the generals who were smart but not as aggressive as those of the first rank. These generals were placed in the second rank. They might not be aggressive enough to create an opportunity but were smart enough to see the opportunity as soon as it was created by the generals of the first rank. These generals would provide the follow on forces.
.
Next comes the generals of the third rank. You might not think that generals who were not smart nor aggressive would not qualify. But these generals could still serve and form generals of the third rank. They can serve behind the lines; in supply for example. Not very smart but not likely to get into any trouble.
.
No, generals of the fourth rank were the ones who were not smart and were aggressive. These were the generals who needed to be dismissed immediately; for they are a danger to all. Donald Trump, I said, is a leader of the fourth rank.
.
The AI version by GPT 5.5:
Editor's Note:
.
(Attributed to Gen. Kurt von Hammerstein-Equord; Born: 26 September 1878 Died: 24 April 1943, Kurt Gebhard Adolf Philipp Freiherr von Hammerstein-Equord. His aristocratic title Freiherr means roughly Baron.
.
Quote Investigator says the original may have appeared in a Berlin newspaper in 1932 or 1933, but that German newspaper source has not been located. (Quote Investigator)
.
Hammerstein is also a strikingly apt source because he was an anti-Hitler German army leader who warned Hindenburg about Hitler and resigned after Hitler’s rise.
.
Earliest located evidence: Army, Navy & Air Force Gazette, Jan. 1933; reprinted as “Selecting Officers,” United States Naval Institute Proceedings, Mar. 1933; Quote Investigator.)
.
Years ago, when Donald Trump first presented himself for national leadership, I recalled an old German military classification often attributed to General Kurt von Hammerstein-Equord.
.
Hammerstein reportedly divided officers into four kinds: the clever and industrious, the clever and lazy, the stupid and lazy, and the stupid and industrious.
.
The clever and industrious could serve well on the General Staff. The clever and lazy might even be suited for the highest command, because they had the clarity and composure to think before acting. The stupid and lazy could be tolerated in routine posts because they were unlikely to do much damage.
.
But the stupid and industrious — the foolish man with energy, impulse, and authority — had to be removed at once, because he was dangerous.
.
That was the category I had in mind when I called Donald Trump a leader of the fourth rank: not merely ignorant, but active; not merely reckless, but energetic in his recklessness; not merely wrong, but dangerous because he acts on what he does not understand.may
.
And in German:
.
Vor Jahren, als Donald Trump sich zum ersten Mal als nationaler Führer präsentierte, erinnerte ich mich an eine alte deutsche militärische Einteilung, die oft General Kurt von Hammerstein-Equord zugeschrieben wird.
.
Hammerstein soll Offiziere in vier Arten eingeteilt haben: die Klugen und Fleißigen, die Klugen und Faulen, die Dummen und Faulen sowie die Dummen und Fleißigen.
.
Die Klugen und Fleißigen konnten gut im Generalstab dienen. Die Klugen und Faulen konnten sogar für die höchsten Führungsaufgaben geeignet sein, weil sie die geistige Klarheit und die innere Ruhe hatten, erst zu denken und dann zu handeln. Die Dummen und Faulen konnte man in Routineposten dulden, weil sie wahrscheinlich wenig Schaden anrichteten.
.
Aber die Dummen und Fleißigen — der törichte Mensch mit Energie, Impuls und Autorität — mussten sofort entfernt werden, weil sie gefährlich waren.
.
Das war die Kategorie, die ich im Sinn hatte, als ich Donald Trump einen Führer vierten Ranges nannte: nicht nur unwissend, sondern tätig; nicht nur leichtsinnig, sondern energisch in seiner Leichtsinnigkeit; nicht nur im Irrtum, sondern gefährlich, weil er nach dem handelt, was er nicht versteht.
.
(Zugeschrieben General Kurt von Hammerstein-Equord; Quote Investigator zufolge könnte das Original 1932 oder 1933 in einer Berliner Zeitung erschienen sein, doch diese deutsche Zeitungsquelle ist bisher nicht gefunden worden. (Quote Investigator)
.
Hammerstein ist außerdem eine besonders passende Quelle, weil er ein deutscher Heeresführer und Gegner Hitlers war, der Hindenburg vor Hitler warnte und nach Hitlers Machtübernahme zurücktrat.
.
Frühester gefundener Beleg: Army, Navy & Air Force Gazette, Jan. 1933; nachgedruckt als „Selecting Officers“, United States Naval Institute Proceedings, März 1933; Quote Investigator.)
.