Wolfean Christian Nationalism shares a lot in common with classical Protestant political theology, however, the implicit and explicit racialism in his Christian Nationalist schema is highly anachronistic to early Protestantism and is largely a modernist identity ideology imported onto older ideals.
The magisterial Protestant tradition did not ground political order in an explicitly racialist, ethnically homogenous nationalism in the way Wolfe does. Whatever their many failures and blind spots, figures like Luther, Calvin, Bucer, Zwingli, and the later Reformed orthodox framed politics in terms of magistracy, law, and the churchâs catholicity, not in terms of preserving a particular modern racialized peopleâgroup as such.
Wolfeâs kinistâleaning ethnonationalism is a distinct, much later development, not just âoldâschool Protestantism.â It has more in common with 1840 Virginia or 1990 Coeur dâAlene, Idaho than Calvinâs Geneva.