I had to sit on this for a bit because this sort of rhetoric absolutely infuriates me. It's not just the values, which are abhorrent (as I'll get to later), but the fundamental dishonesty.
Each individual sentence of this post is technically true. Karmelo Anthony is a black American teen. He has been sentenced to 35 years for murder. The jury did have no black American jurors. There is a history of racial disparity in this country. It is, of course, true that we need moral clarity, and we need to pay attention to who is considered dangerous.
Take each individual statement by itself, & you can't actually contradict it. But there very clearly is a problem of framing here; a very careful, deliberate attempt to leave out the most salient facts of the case, of the history of this country, & of the current character of the problems with race relations to paint a picture that is almost, but not quite, exactly unlike the truth of the matter.
Here's some important facts Bernice left out, in such a precise manner that one can really only surmise she did it on purpose: Karmelo Anthony is, factually, a murderer. 35 years is a reasonable, even light sentence for stabbing someone to death unprovoked. The jury was racially diverse, & the jury selection process was entirely fair, with black American potential jurors removing themselves by admitting they could not be objective in the case. The history of racial disparities in sentencing & punishment in this country is driven largely by actual racial differences in criminal behavior. For the last 60 years, black Americans have enjoyed a legal standing above white Americans in many aspects, for the explicitly stated purpose of righting historical wrongs. And finally, of course, moral clarity requires that we condemn the teenager who stabbed a fellow teenager through the heart, & recognize that the armed person willing to kill someone over a petty interpersonal dispute is the more dangerous party.
Karmelo Anthony, a Black teenager, has been sentenced to 35 years in prison after being convicted by a jury with no Black jurors. Whatever one believes about the verdict itself, we cannot ignore the larger truth that many Americans are wrestling with: justice is still being administered through a system with a long history of racial disparity in sentencing and punishment.
This requires more than reaction. It requires moral honesty about who is deemed dangerous, whose pain is centered, and how differently accountability has often been applied in America. If we want justice worthy of its name, it cannot be shaped by race.
#KarmeloAnthony