Harrumph! 👇
I agree about the eventual and accelerating tokenization of things and am doing my part to contribute, but do you realize that a "real estate debut vault" with "mortgages or property-backed loans" is an actual existing thing?
They are called "eVaults." There is a standards body called MISMO that is governed by the Mortgage Bankers Assoc. and American Land Title Assoc. They mandate an XML schema called an eNote. There is a registry called MERS. A mortgage note is signed in the appropriate XML, placed on the registry, assigned to the owner with a MIN (identifer), and securely stored. When transferred all things are updated, maintaining a ledger of debt ownership and assignment.
The mortgage industry is highly liquid and completely interoperable because of this system. It is integrated with every mortgage originator, warehouse lender, secondary market investor, the GSEs, and every software system across the entire ecosystem. Every participant is on the registry, has a MIN, etc.
MERS was a consortium that was sued by every state and county for decades, finally winning and establishing their legal right to possess and administer this registry... making it enforceable in court when a loan is challenged. Each layer of the stack is audited, makes reps and warranties, etc.
It is also all virtually worthless. Plumbing where players monetize what surrounds it. Each part is bundled and typically free from the companies who generate mortgage docs, provide point of sale systems, etc.
There is literally ZERO incentive for anyone here to change their systems and any participate who does change will require all of their partners to do the same.
Even if you get a few, originators require maximum liquidity. They "best ex" loans, pooling them, and selling to the highest bidder exactly when they want. They cannot be restricted in any way. So you need to upgrade the entire system.
MERS is now owned by ICE who owns the NYSE. They also own Encompass, the largest loan origination system with the vast majority of the market on their platform. Do you not think they themselves will upgrade this system, perhaps more slowly than people would like, but likely all at once and coordinated with the industry...?
I share all this because it frustrates the shit out of me.
So much wasted energy when there are real problems to solve. People should not spend ANY time on the tokenization of real estate assets, they should build value to the underlying process, its steps, and participants. And they should remember that this industry has high $$$ signs, but is terribly low volume and exceptionally difficult to differentiate and win.