CGT: Australia's Great Mining Giveaway:
86% Foreign Owned. 47% Taxed at Home.
x.com/goodfoodgal/status/206…
I'm going to explain why we are the Lucky Country's Last Generation.
Singapore's Lee Kuan Yew once said:
"Australia was indeed a lucky country with an embarrassment of riches" and was "A relaxed, not an intense society."
We no longer own the majority of those "embarrassment of riches", and that "relaxed not intense society" has allowed our politicians to adversely tax our own population while making it progressively easier for foreigners to have the windfall profits, and progressively own Australia's assets.
To illustrate, let's look at how the proposed CGT system works with our mining sector.
Firstly let's totally stun you by looking at the ownership of Australian mining companies....Treasury's own figures confirm our miners are 86% foreign owned... WTF!
australiainstitute.org.au/po…
If you look at every $100 generated by mining company, $30 goes in wages and production, $30 is swiped by state and federal governments (eg royalties), $15 goes to foreigners, $15 goes to suppliers and businesses, and finally $10 goes to Australian shareholders. That's before we are taxed.
Yep, $10.
And now the government wants to slap you with the full blown capital gains tax of 47% on that measly amount of capital gain.
Now those fellas overseas are not going to be paying that, they are probably paying nothing.
And it doesn't stop there, while most Australians pay around 45c per litre in fuel tax, mining companies usually pay nothing, a tax break worth over $3.5 billion to the mining industry each year. A mining industry that is not predominantly owned by Australian companies.
As a proportion of total employment in the country it's about 2%, so they're hardly big employers, compared to over 2 million in health related jobs.
In fact if you look outside of the royalties paid by the miners, as a proportion of overall tax take very little comes from them.
Over the last decade the mining industry paid $254 billion in tax, while total government revenue reached almost $6.8 trillion. So proportionally they pay sweet bugger all.
Who pays the majority of tax? You do, predominantly income tax.
Now they want to shaft you with unprotected capital gains tax as well.
Part of the reason that all this happens is that we are led by people in the video below.
Our politicians tend to be lifelong political hacks, union hacks, occasional lawyers, but almost never successful business people, engineers, doctors, or other technocrats that actually do things to create value. Almost never.
In comparison,China and Singapore go to a great deal of trouble to make sure that their government executive has technocratic skill, as you can see here
x.com/toy59496/status/205992…
All of that mining revenue has not produced a sovereign wealth fund for our descendants, or even a budget surplus for us, but is simply used up on social spending like NDIS. It's a non renewable resource and when it's gone it is gone, and it shows our great contempt for the next generation, and future generations, who will see us as the self-centered halfwit generation who sold them down the river while letting foreigners bask in the bounty of the time.
I don't think this is assisted by having a country where a third of the population were not born here which must at some level weaken our collective intention to look after the integrity of our future generations. If it goes crap they'll just move back. Usually they have somewhere to move back to... We do not.
So now the government wants to tax us more, so we have almost the highest tax rate in the world on income, and with what pitiful residual we get to keep to invest, we then get the highest capital gain tax rate in the world. While foreigners who not only own 86% of our mining companies pay nothing for their capital gain. Obviously that ownership will increase and it is probably so high already because of these asymmetric taxation incentives. I mean how much is left not to own?
Ultimately the good decisions of many of our potential adversaries is infinitely wiser than our own. We will lose the economic war.
Because we are led by people like our finance minister below.