1st century orthodox jews, especially the ones that followed Jesus, were muslims, they believed in God and his messengers, prayed in Jerusalem which is Islam's first direction of prayer before the Kaaba,gave charity,fasted, and they did pilgrimage. Literally the pillars of Islam.
Aramaic Christians still use "Alaha" today; itโs just language. Jesus kept the Jewish Torah, fasted 40 days (not Ramadan), and drank wine. By your logic, 1st-century Orthodox Jews are the best Muslims. Stop culturally appropriating a 1st-century Jew to validate your faith.