My EMNLP paper got desk-rejected post-rebuttal because I posted it to arxiv 25 minutes after the anonymity deadline. I was optimistic about our reviews, so I spent a whole week while visiting my family writing rebuttals and coding experiments to respond.
Just got a desk reject, post-rebuttals, for a paper being submitted to arxiv <30 min late for the anonymity deadline. I talk about how the ACL embargo policy hurts junior researchers and makes ACL venues less desirable for NLP work. I don’t talk about the pointless NOISE it adds.