Opposition's Motion Against Vice President Dhankhar 📢🇮🇳
On December 10, 2024, the opposition INDIA bloc submitted a notice for the removal of Vice President Jagdeep Dhankhar, citing his *partisan conduct* as Chairman of the Rajya Sabha. This unprecedented action reflects concerns over his alleged bias against opposition voices in parliamentary proceedings, which they argue undermines democratic integrity. The motion requires a 14-day notice and a majority vote from the Rajya Sabha and Lok Sabha to proceed, although the opposition lacks sufficient numbers to ensure its passage.
Key Differences Between Impeachment and Removal Procedures 🏛️🔍
**1. Constitutional Basis** 📜
- **Impeachment**:
- Governed by Article 61 for the President.
- Initiated by either House of Parliament.
-
#ConstitutionalFramework 🏛️
- **Removal**:
- Governed by Articles 67(b) (Vice President) and 124(4) (Judges).
- Specific procedures differ based on the office.
-
#RemovalProcedures ⚖️
**2. Grounds for Action** 🚩
- **Impeachment**:
- Grounds include violation of the Constitution.
- Intended for serious misconduct.
-
#HighCrimesAndMisdemeanors ⚠️
- **Removal**:
- Grounds typically involve proven misbehavior or incapacity.
- More focused on performance-related issues.
-
#JudicialAccountability 📉
**3. Initiation Process** 🏁
- **Impeachment**:
- Requires a notice signed by at least one-fourth of members in either House.
- Must be presented after a minimum of 14 days' notice.
-
#InitiationProcess 📝
- **Removal**:
- For Vice President, requires a notice signed by at least 50 members of Rajya Sabha and a simple majority in both Houses.
-
#SimplifiedInitiation ✍️
**4. Investigation Mechanism** 🔍
- **Impeachment**:
- An investigation is conducted by the other House after charges are preferred.
- The accused has the right to defend themselves.
-
#InvestigationProcess 🔎
- **Removal**:
- Involves an inquiry by a committee (for judges), usually comprising legal experts.
- Less formal than impeachment but similarly structured.
-
#InquiryCommittee 👨⚖️
**5. Voting Requirements** 🗳️
- **Impeachment**:
- Requires a two-thirds majority in both Houses of Parliament for removal.
- A more stringent requirement reflecting the gravity of charges.
-
#MajorityVote 📊
- **Removal**:
- For Vice President, requires a simple majority in both Houses after passing through Rajya Sabha first.
-
#SimpleMajority 🏛️
**6. Final Outcome** 🚪
- **Impeachment**:
- If both Houses approve, the President is removed from office immediately upon resolution passage.
-
#ImmediateEffect 🚫
- **Removal**:
- If passed, the Vice President is removed following an address to the President by Parliament.
-
#PresidentialAddress 📬
**7. Historical Context and Precedents** 📚
- **Impeachment**:
- No Indian President has ever faced successful impeachment proceedings.
- Reflects the high threshold for such actions in practice.
-
#HistoricalContext ⏳
- **Removal**:
- Judges have faced removal motions; notable cases include Justice Soumitra Sen, who resigned before removal could be finalized.
-
#JudicialPrecedents ⚖️