#BREAKING: Remember all the claims around the harm that was about to be visited upon John Doe's family in India in California’s
#CiscoCaste lawsuit, if his identity was revealed? Another lie falls apart.
#EqualityLabs argued breathlessly that his parents would be subject to fates worse than death if people knew his last name. You might have forgotten, it was three years ago. But we haven't.
In a vindication for sound jurisprudence,
#California Judge Rosen calls the bluff on claims of great harm if this millionaire’s name was disclosed publicly. In a scathing rebuke, the Judge opined: "If claims of lack of promotion and name-calling from decades ago coupled with generalized statistics of continuing and sometimes violent discrimination were sufficient to allow a person to file anonymously there is scarcely any discrimination case in which a plaintiff could not meet the burden to proceed under a fictitious name."
To recap the
@Cisco case argument:
@calcivilrights (CRD) claimed that caste based discrimination was the primary driver of the treatment meted out to "John Doe." at Cisco. Under threat of sanctions, they dropped the case against the two defendants, the prime accused.
CRD claimed along with John Doe that the threat of harm was so imminent that his identity had to be hidden. Judge Takaichi called the bluff on that argument three years ago.
CRD appealed to the superior court on a technicality and the appeals court conceded the technicality. Demagogues like
@cmkshama hailed that as a great victory.
In her ruling dated December 6, 2023, Judge Rosen denied the request and delivered a major blow.
For background, here is how prime accused
#SundarIyer described the decades long relationship between him and John Doe.
youtube.com/shorts/V1vRRru_e…
Judge's full (and brutal) opinion available at -
cohna.org/wp-content/uploads…
#caste #sb403 #Seattlecastelaw #CasteinUS #SayNoToProfiling