Seoul high court dismisses writers’ appeal in ‘
#ExtraordinaryAttorneyWoo’ dispute, rules Netflix release falls within original contract and cannot be classified under secondary use.
In a significant ruling, the Seoul High Court has dismissed the appeal filed by the Korean Broadcast Writers Association in its lawsuit against production company A Story, upholding the first trial’s decision. The case revolved around the scriptwriting contract for Extraordinary Attorney Woo, with the plaintiffs arguing that the drama’s release on Netflix constituted secondary use beyond its original television broadcast agreement.
The writers’ side maintained that the 2019 contract was based on a traditional TV broadcast model, and therefore, any subsequent sale of rights to an OTT platform like Netflix required additional royalties and compensation. The association had joined the lawsuit after being entrusted with the script’s intellectual property rights by the writer involved.
However, the court rejected these claims, noting that by late 2019, simultaneous distribution across television and OTT platforms had already become an industry norm. It ruled that the contract could not be interpreted as limited to a single medium and instead reasonably covered both broadcast and streaming releases.
The appellate court further emphasized that while certain clauses referenced broadcasting, the overall framework of the agreement did not exclude OTT distribution. It also highlighted that secondary use was contractually defined in cases such as remakes or sequels, suggesting that the production company did not treat OTT streaming as secondary exploitation, ultimately ruling in favor of A Story.
#HallyuForums #Hallyu #KDrama