Is this time different?
Let’s explore the 3 most recent analogs for when the Fed stimulated into similar macro conditions (1984, 1989, and 2007)
In all 3 prior periods we had a setup of Fed reducing rates into:
-stock markets around ATHs
-gold around ATH
-growth was positive
-inflation higher than target
In 1984 and 1989 after the Fed began stimulating we saw a melt up on the stock markets ( 52% and 25% respectively on the S&P after 24 months) while gold mostly moderated after a big run up preceding the Fed stimulus
2007 was the outlier with a stock market meltdown (-27% in the S&P 24 months later) while gold surged 43%
Anyone who’s watched The Big Short knows why 2007 was different, and I acutely remember it as a consultant working on Goldman’s risk team in 07-08
The massive US housing bubble and associated intertwined leverage in the system made that time unique
But this time we have arguments for an AI infra bubble that is showing signs of intertwined leverage 🤔
So the key question is - do we go the path of 84/89 and enjoy a melt up, or do we go the way of 07 and suffer a melt down?
That all depends on whether we enter a credit crisis, so all eyes need to be on the early warning signs
I don’t think the recent commotion in the repo markets is the canary in the coal mine, at least not yet, and broader credit markets still look pretty good
So for the time being, I’m leaning more towards a melt up, and what we should be paying attention to are real interest rates
If real rates compress as bank reserves expand, that should provide the fuel for the melt up scenario and I expect crypto to follow (BTC and some tagalong from majors and select alts, but not all your shitcoins - sorry no alt szn is coming)
TLDR; too early to tell if we do a melt up or melt down so pay attention to credit market weakness and real rates for early signals but for now the melt up is the highest probable outcome imo