You might have missed it if you weren’t looking. 👀
Buried in the 180-page
@HHSGov FY27 budget justification is the proposal for a new Office for Animal Research Protections (OARP).
According to the document, OARP will be tasked with the “development of policy and guidance to protect animal subjects in biomedical and behavioral research” and, fully independent of
@NIH, “will serve a critical role in providing leadership for all federal agencies in protection of rights, wellbeing, and welfare of animals being used in research environments.”
📍
@SAOscience Director, Dr.
@ERoseEngland, contacted HHS for clarification on the new office and spoke with
@TheresaDefino about our optimism and concerns, as well as the giant oversight gap that OARP could fill if given the right direction.
🐭 The current oversight by APHIS and OLAW only reinforces the existing model: animals continue to be used in invasive experiments, while minimal welfare standards define acceptable levels of suffering and don’t address whether animal use is scientifically or ethically justified. If OARP is not given the remit to review the scientific merit of experiments on animals, “it will only serve to give the public another window dressing of progress…and will be another bureaucratic stamp of approval for this cruel, failed paradigm,” Trunnell told Defino.
🐭 If OARP lacks enforcement capabilities, gaps could persist: “As it is now, existing laws and regulations are not enforced and, when they are, [sanctions] are so miniscule that many institutions consider them just the ‘cost of doing business.’”
🐭 Human-based research methods already provide more accurate and clinically relevant data. Ultimately, ending the use of animals in experimentation is the only approach that protects animals’ rights and resolves all welfare failures. “[T]his new office needs to work hand-in-hand with those within HHS, NIH and FDA ... who are working to eliminate experiments on animals” and should “provide much-needed scrutiny on the scientific validity (invalidity, really) of proposed animal experimentation.”
We are “nonetheless “encouraged” by what is known thus far about OARP. “There is a lot of potential and a great need for these activities,” Trunnell said.”
👉 Defino’s piece was published in the
@theHCCA’s Report on Research Compliance, and shared here by
@JDSupra:
jdsupra.com/legalnews/white-…