Tankies on X constantly try to write me off.
“You don’t know China.”
“Go to see Shenzhen, it’s wonderful.”
“You hate China.”
“You’re at Hoover Institute, so I don’t listen to you.” (Yes they can’t even spell “Hoover Institution” properly)
“You haven’t seen the new China.”
Please.
I’ve lived in and stayed in touch with Shenzhen for more than twenty years, since my kindergarten days in Shenzhen. I have close family and personal friends in most of the booming sectors in Shenzhen for the past thirty years.
I’ve got to observe Beijing in close range at its high, low, hiatus, explosive growth, within government, companies, foreign NGOs, local NGOs.
Everyone has a complicated relationship with their home. But unmistakably, I love my home. That is precisely why I levy the strongest, most constant and occasionally harsh criticism at things happening in China. I see into the depth of China’s possibilities and its wasteful squandering of potential, through a persistent totalitarian experiment that yields only servitude and suffering. The only moral thing to do, out of love, is to speak up in the most straight-forward, unapologetic voice, and call evil by its name. You’d do the same for anywhere you love, and seeing it being destroyed day by day.
And yes I’m at Hoover Institution, also known for having the one of the worldwide best archives on China, the China collection at the Hoover Archive, maintained by my colleague and fellow Oxonian historian Hsiaoting, which houses invaluable resources such as Chiang Kaishek’s diary, Li Rui’s diary, HH Kung’s papers, Lin Zhao’s diary, and countless other materials critical to understanding modern China.
The community of China scholars in and around Hoover is impeccable; dare I say the best in the world: Wu Guoguang, former political advisor of general secretary of CCP; Xu Chenggang, Harvard-educated award-winning economist; Elizabeth Economy, former Asia Director at CFR and China Advisor to Sec of Commerce under Biden; Frank Dikotter, bestselling author and renowned historian of modern Chinese history; and ofc Dan Wang, one of the best English-language writers on China right now.
You should find easier targets to launch your low-ball attacks at. Realistically, I’m as deep into the Chinese system as any proficient English-speakers will ever be, barring all those who are too close to party royalties that they cannot speak out loud.
So tankies, a genuine question for you: have you said thank-you once?